A Different Pond by Bao Phi

A Different Pond

As a young boy, Bao Phi awoke early, hours before his father's long workday began, to fish on the shores of a small pond in Minneapolis. Unlike many other anglers, Bao and his father fished for food, not recreation. A successful catch meant a fed family. Between hope-filled casts, Bao's father told him about a different pond in their homeland of Vietnam.

Details A Different Pond

TitleA Different Pond
Release DateAug 1st, 2017
PublisherPicture Window Books
GenreChildrens, Picture Books, Family, Cultural

Reviews A Different Pond

  • Mischenko
    A Different Pond by Bao Phi is a children's book about a family who came to America (Minnesota) from Vietnam as refugees. The story is mainly about Bao and his father's trip to the pond to fetch dinner. During the trip, Bao learns about why his mom and dad have to work so hard for a living as everything has an expense. It's a simple read for young children and the illustrations keep their interest. The book has a graphic novel feel to it and has ...
  • David Schaafsma
    Edited to reflect that A Different Pond, a book I love, was given a Caldecott Honor Book Award for 2018, yay! Much deserved! My favorite of the Goodreads picture book nominees of the year. And yes, I think whether you are have kids at home or not that you should get picture books from the library; many are just amazing.Original 11/22/17 review: Each year my family reads all the Goodreads-award-nominated picture books, and we have been doing this ...
  • destiny ☠ howling libraries
    Assigned reading for MLIS 7421: Multicultural Youth Literature.There's not a lot to this book, but that's part of why it works so well; it's just a story of a little boy, the youngest in a family of Vietnamese immigrants, waking up early on a Saturday morning to go fishing for dinner with his father while musing over the idea of his father as a child, fishing on a Saturday morning in a very similar pond, on the other side of the globe. It touches...
  • Deb (Readerbuzz) Nance
    It's a simple story of a boy and his father rising early to go fishing before the father must go to work at his second job, but it's also the rich intersections between the American and Vietnamese cultures, between the old and the new lives. The illustrations are lush and filled with lots of space for the quiet and for the spaces between the boy and his father and for the lack of things in their lives. A wonderful story.
  • Danielle
    This completely drew me in with its descriptive, beautiful language and imagery. The story of a boy going fishing with his father early one Saturday morning in order to feed the family is about so much more.
  • Carla Johnson-Hicks
    This is a great story to read when studying about multi-culturalism, heritage, and customs around the world. Bao, a young Vietnamese boy wakes very early on a Saturday morning to go fishing with his father in a pond nearby. He explains that everything in America is expensive, and even though he is working two jobs, he still has to fish for dinner. While they are together, the father tells Bao about fishing in another pond far away, as well as a b...
  • Shauna Yusko
    Love this one so much! Why have I not read it before now?!
  • Elizabeth A
    "A kid at my school said my Dad's English sounds like a thick, dirty river. But to me his English sounds like gentle rain."The immigrant experience is both universal and unique, and this picture book for kids explores themes of displacement, family, and making sense of the world around you. I'm delighted that there is more diversity in books available for kids this days, and while I appreciated this one, I enjoyed the art more than the actual tex...
  • Michael
    Beautiful in its simplicity. Highly recommended.
  • Richie Partington
    Richie’s Picks: A DIFFERENT POND by Bao Phi and Thi Bui, ill., Capstone, August 2017, 32p., ISBN: 978-1-62370-803-0“Dad wakes me quietly so Mom can keep sleeping. It will be hours before the sun comes up.In the kitchen the bare bulb is burning. Dad has been up for a while, making sandwiches and packing the car.‘Can I help?’ I ask.‘Sure,’ my dad whispers and hands me the tackle box.”With quiet, transcendent words and illustrations, t...
  • Alex (not a dude) Baugh
    In an age that is seeing an increase in the number of refugees fleeing their countries seeking safety comes a simple, but powerful semi-autobiographical story from poet Bao Phi. Phi, his parents and siblings were refugees from Vietnam who came to the United States in 1975. And as with most refugees, those early years were difficult. Early one morning before the sun has even risen, Phi's father wakes up his son from a sound sleep to go fishing. Hi...
  • Andrea Lorenz
    Bao Phi tells the story of an early early morning fishing trip with his father. The trip is not for recreation; it is for food. Bao's father and mother immigrated to America from Vietnam and worked hard to raise a family. A Different Pond is a quiet book, but it tells an important story. The lives of immigrants are frequently more challenging than those of natives - Bao talks about his father's English, how hard his parents have to work, how ever...
  • BookishDubai
    A bit too simple for my taste.
  • Jeimy
    Simple, elegant story inspired by the author's childhood of the sacrifices parents make to offer their children a better life than the ones they had while growing up.
  • Joan
    Well, this counts as a diverse story and it is lovely. It is good to see the publishing field continuing the push for diversity and rewarding it. This is a Caldecott Honor Award. The unnamed small boy, pre-K level age, is awakened by his father at what must have been something like 2 or 3 AM. They quietly collect supplies and go to the bait store and pick up bait. They then head to a local pond (with a no trespassing sign). While Dad fishes, our ...
  • Theresa
    I was fortunate to receive this Caldecott Honor Nominee at BEA 2018. This simple story of a father/son fishing trip is powered by the emotionally detailed artwork, specifically the endearing facial expressions of the characters. This is a quiet story about family, immigrants, culture, home and hope that transports the reader. Both the writer and illustrator were born in Vietnam and raised in the US. Adults should also read illustrator Thi Bui’s...
  • Lori
    A Vietnamese immigrant father and his son go fishing before sun-up. Unlike most Americans who fish for sport, this family fishes because it provides food for the table. The father works multiple jobs, and even the mother works to meet the high cost of living in the United States. It could provide interesting discussion moments for children as they savor the beautiful illustrations.
  • Kathryn
    Such a poignant story one that can be understood by children and adults.
  • Jordan Henrichs
    Might not be the central point of this text, but what stood out to me was the sacrifice made by the mother and father to give the family a better life down the road.
  • Maggi Rohde
    A quiet portrait of a Vietnamese father and his young son, doing what needs to be done to get by in America. Touching and evocative, this is a perfect exemplar text for writing workshop (2nd-3rd).
  • Elisabeth
    Beautiful. I want to read this one over and over.
  • Bill
    “Dad wakes me quietly so Mom can keep sleeping. It will be hours before the sun comes up.” Thus begins A Different Pond, a lovely, quiet little tale of a young boy who goes fishing with his immigrant father, written by Bao Phi and illustrated by Thi Bui. Together they get up early, pick up bait at the shop, make their way to their usual pond, catch a few fish, then head home just as the sun begins to rise.One of the major themes of the story ...
  • Ilana
    A young boy wakes early in the morning, on a weekend day, to join his father for a couple of hours for fishing in a pond nearby. The time spent together is an opportunity to share life stories, especially from the 'old country', but also short remarks about life. 'Everything in America costs a lot of money, he explains. I feel callouses in his hand when he squeezes mine'. Both the writer and the illustrator were born in Vietnam and arrived in the...
  • Elizabeth Willis
    "A kid at school said my dad's English sounds like a think, dirty river... But to me his English sounds like gentle rain."
  • Lizzie
    Everyday moments of son and his immigrant during a early morning fishing trip. Powerful in its' tenderness.
  • Radhika
    A wonderful read. A connection between father and son and of the different cultures. A childs view of his father and what he feels about being in a different world where the parents belong to another culture and are ridiculed by his peers. But he loves them and enjoys the fishing expedition with his dad and enjoys the love of the familyA wonderful story for young kids and the illustrations are out of this world!
  • DaNae
    A lovely window into an immigrant family's story. As they carve an American life, that so many of us have the luxury of taking for granted.
  • Mia Wenjen
    A dignified portrayal of poverty experienced by an Vietnamese immigrant family.
  • Linda
    I have memories that make me both happy and sad, and love books that are both celebrations of the past, though sad, and show how people live in spite of hard things. This is the way Bao Phi has told this story of rising very early with his father to go to a pond to catch dinner. One line shows the family’s need, something I’ve never experienced. The boy in the story, Bao’s dad says “Got one.” then a little later, Bao shares, “Dad smil...