Chaotic Good by Whitney Gardner

Chaotic Good

Cameron's cosplay--dressing like a fictional character--is finally starting to earn her attention--attention she hopes to use to get into the CalTech costume department for college. But when she wins a major competition, she inadvertently sets off a firestorm of angry comments from male fans.When Cameron's family moves the summer before her senior year, she hopes to complete her costume portfolio in peace and quiet away from the abuse. Unfortunat...

Details Chaotic Good

TitleChaotic Good
Release DateMar 13th, 2018
GenreYoung Adult, Contemporary, Romance, LGBT, Fiction

Reviews Chaotic Good

  • Elise (TheBookishActress)
    I have really loved both of Whitney Gardner's contemporaries so far. Both are quite different from the usual cute fluffy romances / issue books that I seem to pick up all the time. She's got a strong writing voice, fantastic concepts, and a great commitment to casual diversity. Her debut was a romance-free book about a Deaf street artist and the friendship she forms with a girl at her school. Her second novel is about a nerd girl who dresses as a...
  • Kat
    Cute and full of fandom-y moments. Cameron, who loves cosplay, is sick of being treated differently in fandom by guys because she happens to be a girl. When she goes into a comic book store, and is made fun of by the shop’s owner, she’s annoyed enough that with the help of her brother Cooper, she disguises herself as a boy the next time. All sorts of crazy nerdy fandom stuff ensues, including lots of Dungeons and Dragons and costume making. I...
  • Brooke — brooklynnnnereads
    I really enjoyed this book and it was a pleasant surprise because admittedly, I didn't think I was going to enjoy this book as much as I did. When I first started this novel, it seemed very different to the content that I would typically read about. Although I would consider myself a fairly "nerdy" female, I don't know very much about comics, cosplay, or Dungeons and Dragons. So when all of these things were introduced, I was pretty hesitant and ...
  • Fafa's Book Corner
    Review posted on Fafa's Book Corner! Beware spoilers ahead!Trigger warning: Cyber bullyingI heard about Chaotic Good through GR. It hasn't really been that well advertised or talked about. The synopsis reminded me off Moxie which I read and thoroughly enjoyed. I am happy to say that I enjoyed it!Cameron (Cam for short) and her family has just recently moved to Eugene. Cameron is a cosplayer and really wants to get into the university of her d...
  • Vani
    THERE AREN’T EVEN WORDS. I INHALED Chaotic Good. I read it in one sitting and will absolutely, definitely be buying a copy to read again. It’s my favorite book of the year. Of several years. Let’s get into it.The premise of Chaotic Good intrigued me immediately, because your girl is a nerd. I’ve played D&D, Call of Cthulhu. I’ve spent many a Friday night in a room with a bunch of dudes playing tabletop games. I kicked EVERYONE’S ass a...
  • Erica
    Dear audience for whom this is intended (cosplayers, D&D players, comic book readers, nerdy young adults and people who adore YA fiction, LGBTQA+ allies, geek feminists, people who are just now becoming concerned with gender norms and violence against women and people who do not conform to white American Christian values): Go get this book immediately. I think you will love it.I do not love it.I had it in my mind, from looking at the cover and do...
  • Abi (The Knights Who Say Book)
    *I received an advance reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review*My two impressions of this book:1. Wow! So cute and feminist and fun!2. Holy prolonged drama, Batman! I can say that without knowing anything about Batman, because this book is about being allowed to enjoy comics however you choose to, dammit.Let's go in order.Cute and feminist and fun? So good. I love that Cameron's a cosplayer and that costume design is an importan...
  • Gabrielle (Wishes she had more time to read)
    I wrote a discussion review of this fantastic book with Mishma last year, and because I've gotten so bad at this blogging this, never got around to writing a proper review for this book, myself. I need to rectify this, soon.I will say this for now: Chaotic Good is funny, wholesome and filled with heart. Whitney Gardner writes in an honest, passionate voice that leaps off the page and demands you to feel right along with Cameron. It was, somehow...
  • Danielle (Life of a Literary Nerd)
    “Chaotic good ones place a high value on free will: they always intend to do the right thing, even if their methods are haphazard and generally out of sync with the rest of society.” Such a fun book!!!! I didn’t love You’re Welcome Universe when I read it last year, but Choatic Good is one of the best fandomy contemporaries I’ve read recently! We follow Cameron, an aspiring costume designer, who loves cosplaying comic characters. Camer...
  • Samantha (WLABB)
    Fandoms and the Internet can get a girl down, but it might be ok, when she has a great group of people to support her. #pinzhasaposse. Loved so many things about this one. Loved the art, the story, the characters, the D&D, and so much more. ===========================================================================The title of this book is a nod to a common character trope. Gardner explains:Chaotic good ones place a high value on free will: they ...
  • laurel [suspected bibliophile]
    Holy guacamole.Guys.GuysGUYS.This book (view spoiler)[actual rating 4.5 .5 deduction because of the abrupt ending (I WANT MORE!) (hide spoiler)] is the shit. It reminded me a lot of Eliza and Her Monsters and Fangirl.I totally felt Cameron and her struggles as a girl-nerd living in a nerdom ruled by boys, most of whom resemble something that lives underneath a slimy bridge...or deep in a parent's basement. This book explores the differing levels ...
  • Laura (bbliophile)
    I really enjoyed how cute, feminist and nerdy this was, but I'm very disappointed that in a book about cross-dressing, there's not one mention of non-binary people. Nothing. Full review to come.
  • Yvonne Olson
    Oh, I definitely needed this book in my life.I remember being at work about a month ago, looking over the Kirkus reviews and seeing Chaotic Good. The first reaction I had was "Oh, that's so cool!" because I had never seen a DnD inspired contemporary. My second reaction is "I want to read this so bad." I immediately crossed my fingers and hoped it would be on Netgalley. To my delight, it was - and I got a galley!I think I read this book in 3 hours...
  • Meg Eden
    ALL OF THE STARS. Chaotic Good by Whitney Gardner takes a unique and raw angle at both the joys and problems of being in the nerd community, particularly as a female. It follows Cameron, a cosplay seamstress and rising D&D player as she moves to a new town and tries to find her bearings in both in-person and online conflicts. The integration of comics is amazing, and really helps clarify what is D&D storyline and what is Cameron’s everyday stor...
  • Cody Roecker
    I've decided that Whitney Gardner's novels are perfectly my style. This book is wholesomely nerdy. Dungeons & Dragons and Cosplay. It's the most beautifully nerdy thing I've read in a long time. the art reminded me of Noelle Stevenson's NIMONA, and the story inside matched the heart of it all. I absolutely loved Cam, her grit, her love for costume making. Cam is one of those girls that is determined and committed to anything she does. and I loved...
  • Kelli O'Malley
    I wanted to love this book so badly. When I picked it up, I finished reading it within a day. It started off so strong, the characters were solid, likeable, and real. The story was familiar and so true to life. But what killed this book for me was the ending. Not only did the writing quality go down hill in the last half of the book, but the ending itself felt like a slap in the face. I think I had such a visceral reaction because I saw myself in...
  • Sky
    4.5 rounded up. It wasn’t perfect, but it was pretty darn close.
  • Jamie (Books and Ladders)
    See this review and more on Books and Ladders!Actual Rating: 4.5*I loved this so so much. The opening pages are things that have actually stopped me from participating in certain geek things. It was so nice to have my story told. I thought the ending was a little too easy but I loved every second of this entire book. Definitely a must read if you are sick of being called a fake geek girl.
  • Emmy Ruijven
    Geeky girls unite!
  • Hilda
    This was ridiculously cute and full of so much comic books and nerdy homage!! I loved it from start to finish. Even towards the end when the shit hit the fan. I was so invested emotionally. I needed her to succeed and overcome. I loved Cameron so much. But what really stole the show for me was the emotional connection with all the characters. I loved the relationship between the twins and their parents. The connection to each other. There’s thi...
  • nick
    I loved this! It's a charming and fiercely feminist story that made my heart so full!
  • Karissa
    I got a copy of this book to review through the Amazon Vine program. This was a fun and cute read. It is mostly about coming of age and a girl trying to be comfortable with who she is in the geek culture world. There is also a lot about internet trolls harassing her and how poorly some men treat women that they think are invading their geek culture turf.I loved some of the relationship twists and turns and loved the DnD references even more. The ...
  • Jamie-leigh Haughn
    If you love all thing geeky/nerdy then you are going to LOVE this book! This book gave me so many She's The Man vibes, I can't even express how happy that made me! This story follows Cam, a young fashionista who designs costumes for cosplay, in her attempt to create a new look and a new life for herself in a new town. She feels that she isn't taken seriously in the comic book world as a woman and decides to dress up as a boy to get better insight...
  • Anna
    This was lovely. Despite how most of us are aware of sexism in our modern society, this was the first time I ever truly witnessed from a male point of view how much power men truly command over women, even when not being openly sexist. Chaotic Good was like She's the Man... only so much better. I don't play D&D, sew, or cosplay, but that didn't stop me from falling in love with Cameron's story & the band of friends she finds herself falling into.
  • Brie
    Delightful and awesome! These characters are so touching, their stories so sweet and real, my heart skipped a beat when I finished and then fell when I realized it was over. More to come closer to release date, but put this one on your TBR stat, you won't regret it.
  • Rachel Kamery / Never Enough Novels
    3.5 Stars - I'd love to see more young adult / fiction novels that feature geek culture, Dungeons & Dragons, and cosplay! However, this was a bit heavy handed on the "men are sexist pigs" narrative. Thankfully, my experience in this nerdy realm has been extremely positive and I'm hoping most other women haven't had to deal with anything close to the level of hatred showcased here. Besides that point, this was a fun ride and an adorable love story...
  • Jamie Winter
    In the aftermath of Gamergate and the havoc wrecked on geek girls on the internet comes a young adult contemporary about a female cosplayer finding herself the target of online hate. Cameron is an aspiring costume designer who wants nothing more than to make the fantastical costumes for all things nerdy. When a slip of the tongue throws her into a debate on ‘fake geek girls’ and judgment from the local comic shop manager Cameron and her twin ...
  • Kimberly
    Thank you @kidlitexchange for the review copy of this book. All opinions are my own. Another young adult book that took me completely by surprise. It was entertaining, full of great characters and contained an unique storyline that touched on some really important topics. Cameron is into cosplay and has a wonderful talent for making costumes. Her work and blog had recently received quite a bit of attention and not in a positive way. Everyone seem...
  • McKinlay Dennis
    *I received a DRC from netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review*I thought this was a fun, fast read that kind of explores what it's like to be a female in the nerd/geek community. I've been in the community for many years and have never really had my "cred" called into question. I'm pretty sure it's because i'm not what you'd call, attractive? But i've seen girls get torn down time and time again for being "fake geeks" and it'...