Heartland by Sarah Smarsh

Heartland

During Sarah Smarsh’s turbulent childhood in Kansas in the 1980s and 1990s, the forces of cyclical poverty and the country’s changing economic policies solidified her family’s place among the working poor. By telling the story of her life and the lives of the people she loves, Smarsh challenges us to look more closely at the class divide in our country and examine the myths about people thought to be less because they earn less. Her persona...


Details Heartland

TitleHeartland
ISBN9781501133091
Author
Release DateSep 18th, 2018
PublisherScribner
LanguageEnglish
GenreNonfiction, Autobiography, Memoir, Biography, Economics, Biography Memoir
Rating

Reviews Heartland

  • Richard Derus
    2018-10-23
    Real Rating: 2.5* of fiveDNF @ 41%Entirely because the book is written as though to the author's unborn—nay, unconceived—daughter. It's simply too cutesy-poopsie-woopsie a conceit for me. I love the style of the author's sentences, and I appreciate the depth and quality of her research. This topic...the immense and widening gap between Haves and Have Nots, the cultural forces behind the pernicious lie of class, the racism inherent in judging ...
  • Elizabeth
    2018-09-07
    tl;dr: I was really excited about Heartland but a gimmick makes it fall flat.I was giddy when I heard about Heartland--finally, a book had come along with the power of Nickled and Dimed!Sadly, despite the glowing blurb from Barbara Ehrenreich, Heartland is not that powerful. Even for a memoir, it lacks impact There is one thing Ms. Smarsh does well in Heartland, and that's provide a nuanced look into the women of her immediate family. She's clear...
  • Jenna
    2019-03-25
    "The American Dream has a price tag on it. The cost changes depending on where you’re born and to whom, with what color skin and with how much money in your parents’ bank account. The poorer you are, the higher the price. This is the book I'd hoped Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis would be but wasn't. Sarah Smarsh grew up poor in a dysfunctional farming family in Kansas. In this book, she talks about her childhood, ...
  • Clif Hostetler
    2018-09-24
    This is a very well written memoir that not only recounts memories of growing up in Kansas (30 miles west of Wichita), but ponders the plight of working class poor with a deeply humane sensitivity that offers clarifying insight into social conditions of the heartland. In addition to the intimate details of family history the book’s narrative reviews the history of the Homestead Act, the progressive politics of early Kansas statehood, the farmin...
  • Diane
    2019-01-30
    This is a memoir that has really good content — a great discussion of social class and poverty in middle America — but the author's decision to write the book as if she were addressing her unborn child drove me bonkers.* And yet, Sarah Smarsh has a good life story to share, so I kept reading and tried to ignore the pretentious writing style. Sarah grew up in rural Kansas in a hardworking family that was constantly trying to stay afloat. Sarah...
  • Michelle
    2018-09-17
    “Heartland: A Memoir of Working Hard and Being Broke in The Richest Country on Earth” is a resounding story by Sarah Smarsh of her family life, heritage and farming culture on the Kansas prairie. With the passage of the Homestead Act (1862) over 270 million acres of land was available for settlement on the American plains. Settlers could receive up to 160 acres of land at no cost if they lived and cultivated their land for a period of five ye...
  • M
    2018-10-04
    I read this book with much anticipation after hearing the author interviewed on the New York Times Book Review Podcast. The small town upbringing, the succeeding despite difficult challenges, being the first of your clan to earn a college degree, etc., rang true with me. But I was disappointed in the execution and underwhelmed by the writing.The contrived literary device of speaking to a never-born child, (usually out of the clear blue and withou...
  • Jennifer Blankfein
    2018-12-08
    Follow my reviews on Book Nation by Jen. https://booknationbyjen.wordpress.comIt is possible that I have overdosed on stories about indigence and the cultural divide, so for me, Sarah Smarsh’s message was strong yet her story felt repetitive. Smarsh tells us about her family and how their extreme poverty lead to generations of teenaged pregnancies, drinking, abuse, lack of education, bad or absent parenting, and all the while her family worked ...
  • Rebecca
    2018-11-10
    (3.5) If you were a fan of Hillbilly Elegy by J.D. Vance, then Heartland deserves to be on your radar too. Smarsh comes from five generations of Kansas wheat farmers and worked hard to step outside of the vicious cycle that held back the women on her mother’s side of the family: poverty, teen pregnancy, domestic violence, broken marriages, a lack of job security, and moving all the time. Like Mamaw in Vance’s book, Grandma Betty is the star o...
  • Janilyn Kocher
    2018-08-02
    Heartland is a great read. I enjoyed Smarsh's family history immensely. However, I'm not buying her assertion that she grew up in poverty. I suppose my definition of poverty differs from hers. She always had a roof over her head and food to eat. Smarsh never had to live in a car or under a bridge as many people have. From my perspective, Smarsh was rich in love and perseverance that she learned from her family. Various family members spent a fort...
  • Kathleen
    2018-10-05
    National Book Award for Nonfiction Longlist 2018. Smarsh has chosen to write about her own family’s multigenerational struggle in Kansas to get ahead by working any way that they could to make ends meet. She focuses particularly on her female relatives and how their decisions contributed to their poverty—her mother, grandmother, and great-grandmother all had their first child at 16-years-old. Having children at such a young age causes them to...
  • Paul
    2018-08-18
    Heartland belongs on the shelf next to books like Desmond’s Evicted, Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy, and Ehrenreich’s Nickle and Dimed. Smarsh’s book provides a strong voice for and about breaking the destructive cycles of families, the economics of class, and the fact that birth should not be the reigning mark of future prospects. Smarsh is a talented writer who tells the story of her grandparents, parents, and extended family with clarity and ...
  • Brad
    2018-08-04
    As a lifelong Kansan who came from a working class family in Topeka but knew nothing of the life of the rural parts of my state, I declare this essential reading. Essential not just for Kansans like me, but for so many who have no idea what rural poverty looks like. Sarah Smarsh recounts the story of her family--most notably the women who held the family together--while also weaving it into the larger dynamics of an increasingly crueler American ...
  • Brandi
    2018-06-03
    I like reading about lives that are very different from my own. Sarah Smarsh is a good writer, and it was interesting to learn her family history and her views on the world. But I really wish this book had been organized chronologically instead of thematically. She jumped around in time, which made it hard to keep track of her many relatives and what they were doing. And I’m not really sure what each chapter’s theme was supposed to be, since ...
  • Elizabeth A.G.
    2018-12-04
    This is an inspiring memoir that not only reveals the multi-generational familial story of the author's life, but also delves into the greater societal issues of the working poor. Sara Smarsh confronts, in hindsight and from personal experience, the economic woes of farming and minimum wage work in the changing national narrative of business, profits, and class inequality in the Kansas heartland. Economic policy changes as in the Homestead Act, t...
  • Jerrie (redwritinghood)
    2018-10-16
    From the NBA shortlist for non-fiction comes this memoir about growing up poor in a “flyover” state. While I can agree with a lot of what she says about growing up in a rural setting, I sometimes felt she over-dramatized some of it. That in addition to the weird way of talking to her ‘daughter’ throughout made this more of a so-so read for me.
  • Lindsey
    2018-09-24
    From the moment I head about this book I knew I had to read it, because I knew in a sense it would be a book about me and my people. Other than Julene Bair's One Degree West, there aren't many books about what it is like growing up in rural Kansas, "flyover country."At one point Sarah Smarsh writes, "there was no language for whatever I represented on campus." Like Sarah, I grew up poor (though not in the kind of abject poverty and abuse that she...
  • Cow
    2018-11-08
    I had such high hopes, given the reviews I'd read and the accolades this book is getting. But...wow, no.First, it's written as a letter to her non-existent child, which is a completely unearned gimmick that takes what seems like a serious memoir and turns it into being too cute by half. But that's fine, because so is the writing--so many tortured metaphors, so many too-cute turns of phrases, it read like an extended New Yorker piece.When she's wr...
  • Stephanie
    2018-07-21
    Many years ago, I read Barbara Ehrenreich’s Nickel and Dimed and it knocked my socks off. When I saw Sarah Smarsh’s Heartland had been favorably compared to it and recommended to people who liked it, I jumped at the opportunity (provided by Scribner and NetGalley) to read it in exchange for my honest review.First of all, thanks a LOT, Sarah! I was awake most of the night reading, then thinking about this book! Like The Glass Castle, so many t...
  • John Bohnert
    2018-12-29
    I would have enjoyed this book much more if it was linear.The book made me appreciate how lucky I was growing up in my blue collar family.We were poor. A family of five living in an eighteen-foot-long trailer in a trailer park.The trailer didn't even have a bathroom. We had an icebox that needed blocks of ice.My folks didn't do drugs, drink, or even smoke cigarettes like many of the characters in this book.Dad worked hard but we lived paycheck to...
  • Jaclyn Crupi
    2018-12-05
    If you’re thinking of writing your memoir about class and poverty to your not-yet-born/never-to-be-born daughter ’August’ my advice is – don’t. It’s weird and unneccessarily distracting.
  • Barbara
    2019-01-10
    This memoir tells a story that is seldom heard - a story of the lives of poor people in America who are white. Sarah Smarsh grew up on a farm in rural Kansas, moving between there and Wichita throughout her childhood. Her mother and grandmother had both become mothers at age 16. Sarah escaped that life, but to her credit her memoir focuses on telling the story of poor Kansas farmers.The best part of this memoir is the focus on women living in pov...
  • Suzanne
    2018-09-17
    Strong initial effort by author Sarah Smart combines memoir with facts and figures to further explain her family’s hardships over the last century. This combination approach is a difficult one to pull off because readers are constantly pulled from the engaging family narrative and flung head first into demographic data explaining the larger state/national issues. But the most disruptive element of the book is the almost constant reference to th...
  • Melissa Stacy
    2019-02-15
    I purchased a copy of the 2018 memoir, "Heartland: A Memoir of Working Hard and Being Broke in the Richest Country on Earth," by Sarah Smarsh, after this book became a National Book Award nonfiction finalist in 2018.This memoir was massively disappointing, and overall frustrating to read. If you have read any of these nonfiction books -- "Nickel and Dimed," "Evicted," "Hillbilly Elegy," "The Other America," "Behind the Beautiful Forevers," "Rando...
  • Melanie
    2018-10-24
    I wanted to like this book, because the author has such an important point of view to share, but she has made a muddle of it. I understand memoirs not being in chronological order, especially from chapter to chapter, but this author jumps around from page to page. I made it to page 225 of 288 before I skimmed the rest, because I couldn't handle the jumping around anymore.A family tree would have been nice. Her maternal grandmother is only like 8 ...
  • Marian
    2018-08-15
    I had hoped to be keener on this one. Best feature for me were the stories of the grandmothers and mother.
  • Kayo
    2018-07-31
    Wasn't what I was expecting. Not up to Nickel and Dimed, not that I compared. Not thrilled that I could't give a review for months after I got it from Netgalley! Thanks to author, publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book. While I got the book for free, it hadno bearing on the rating I gave it.
  • Alison
    2018-10-02
    In a sense it's a shame that this book is being marketed as a window into understanding the white working class. Lumping this title in with crappy, moralistic screeds (I'm thinking mainly here of Hillbilly Elegy) in order to sell more books doesn't do Smarsh's work justice. It's a beautifully written memoir, you could teach it in an English class, and it explores so much more than just the white working class as we "understand" it through repetit...
  • Laurie's Lit Picks
    2018-08-26
    For those of you who loved My Name is Lucy Barton, or Nickled and Dimed, or Hillbilly Elegy, you will need to add this book to your TBR pile. Debut author Sarah Smarsh chronicles her life, and generations of her family, as they try and survive living and toiling in Kansas during the past century. The difference in this story for me was the fact that it is told from a female perspective, as well as focusing on the matriarchal struggles of generati...