Trick Mirror by Jia Tolentino

Trick Mirror

Trick Mirror is an enlightening, unforgettable trip through the river of self-delusion that surges just beneath the surface of our lives. This is a book about the incentives that shape us, and about how hard it is to see ourselves clearly in a culture that revolves around the self. In each essay, Jia writes about the cultural prisms that have shaped her: the rise of the nightmare social internet; the American scammer as millennial hero; the liter...

Details Trick Mirror

TitleTrick Mirror
Release DateAug 6th, 2019
PublisherRandom House
GenreNonfiction, Writing, Essays, Feminism, Autobiography, Memoir

Reviews Trick Mirror

  • Roxane
    This is an outstanding, rigorously researched and written collection of cultural criticism. I really admired the depth of thought here. I felt like each essay was a master class on how to write cultural criticism. I was definitely taking notes. Some of the essays ran too long and could use some tightening but that is a subjective opinion. I was particularly interested in the essay about the UVA rape case and the one about uncritical feminism and ...
  • Melanie
    I'd read Jia Tolentino's grocery lists if she let me.
  • Thomas
    4.5 starsI have to start this review by sharing that when I finished the last essay of Trick Mirror, I Thee Dread, I literally started clapping and whisper screaming oh my god, Jia really did that and ugh, queen of delivering a fatal blow to the capitalist patriarchal wedding industrial complex, we stan a self-aware icon. Mind you, this fanboying took place while I sat alone on my couch in my apartment, where Im typing this review right now. I Th...
  • Jiaqi
    I feel awful terrible giving such a low review because i was so so so excited for this to the point where I refused to read any press so I could have a pure unmediated experience... but only like 3 of the essays in here were good: the ones where she reflects on her own life. Which is funny because I used to get kind of annoyed at the way she would unnecessarily drop in details about her life into unrelated articles à la girl-who-went-to-Barthelo...
  • Michael
    Lucid and enlightening, the essays of Jia Tolentinos debut collection Trick Mirror: Reflections on Self-Delusion consider what it means for Millennial women to navigate a culture of spectacle, scam, and oppression. In sharp prose across nine essays Tolentino takes on everything from the troubling rise of athleisure to Americas obsession with reality television, difficult women, and weddings. Sketching brilliant fragments of cultural criticism for...
  • Oriana
    Recently my rad friend B and I got into it about Roxanne Gay's Bad Feminist, which I loudly do not like. B argued that it was wrong of me to judge it so harshly because I was not taking into account the deep biases I bring to my own reading. I remain unrepentant because those essays are extremely bad, but I do acknowledge that I am only a combination of my life's influences: I grew up solidly middle-class, I am a cis-het woman and a Jew of Europe...
  • emma
    Here is who I recommend this book for: Anyone who has been in a coma for the last ten to fifteen years; a person who just discovered the internet, or perhaps only recently learned how to read; someone over the age of 70 or under the age of 10 who has a suddenly discovered interest in small and generally feminist happenings of recent years.Everyone else, youre probably covered.There is nothing much new here.This pains me to say, because I like Jia...
  • Julie Ehlers
    So what's a trick mirror, anyway? Seriously, what is it? I googled three different ways and all I found was references to this book. (If you know, please tell me in the comments! Edit: Thanks, Marchpane!) I'm assuming a trick mirror is a mirror that shows you something different depending on how you look at it, blurring the lines between what's real and what isn't. If I'm right, it's an apt title for the book as well as an apt description of the ...
  • Elyse Walters
    Audiobook... narrated by the author, Jia Tolentino.I really enjoyed listening to Jia read her book - (9 essays). Shes bluntly insightful about the times we are living in without being preachy. I admire the way Jia formulates her thoughtsbrilliantly! I became so curious about this magnificent woman, ( never knew of her until now), that I spent time listening to her YouTube interviews. I liked her even more! There is something of value for everyone...
  • Nicola
    A bit of a mixed bag. Highlights: The first essay, The I in Internet, is excellent. Always Be Optimizing had some great ideas but a bit circular and seemed to be holding something back. The personal experience essays, Reality TV Me and Ecstacy were diverting enough, I enjoyed them. Downsides:Some of the essays cover some really well-worn ground at this point. Often, the context and asides are too heavy on research and info-dumping that isnt fully...
  • Maxwell
    I enjoy Tolentino's writing a lot. The standout essay to me is still "Ecstasy" which I read back when it came out in the New Yorker earlier this year. Some of her ideas are left a bit unexamined, in my view. They were more explanatory than critical, so as a primer in contemporary topics, it's great. But it did leave a bit to be desired.
  • Blair
    I don't know if Im going to have the time to write about this in the depth I would like, so I will just say that I finished Trick Mirror feeling Id probably read any article Jia Tolentino writes about any topic, and Id definitely read her memoirs. The personal stories woven through these essays bring the book to vibrant life. The autobiographical essays tend to be the strongest, particularly Reality TV Me, in which Tolentino revisits her experien...
  • Matthew Quann
    An easy personal stand-out for personal non-fiction book of the year, Trick Mirror is an essay collection that touches on feminism, its intersection with the internet, our modern preoccupations with external appearance, and honestly staggering amounts of other good stuff. It's a bit tough to summarize a book that features an essay of complex analysis of the institute of marriage alongside one about taking ecstasy, religion, and DJ Screw. Suffice ...
  • Lisa
    [3.5] I can see why this collection has been received with such acclaim. The focus on cultural criticism with a theme of self delusion is perfect for our times. Tolentino is smart, insightful and her essays are well researched. Yet... I personally feel oversaturated with input on our consumer and millennial culture. I am mostly lukewarm about her essays on the internet, reality tv, optimization, Ecstasy, and scamming. Finally though - her last th...
  • Rachel
    I'm pleased to report that it's every bit as good as everyone says it is.  Jia Tolentino probes the oddities of modern [female] life with the precision of a scalpel; she's a tremendously talented writer and a skilled observer, a critical combination when it comes to this sort of essay collection.  My favorite essay was the one about Tolentino's time on a reality tv show as a teenager, and my least favorite was the last essay about weddings, but...
  • Hannah
    This is an incredibly strong essay collection, brought down by a first essay that did not work for me and made picking this back up difficult for me. But once I finished that first essay, Jia Tolentino gives the reader an incredibly well-structured and presented collection. I know why this was one of my most anticipated reads for this year.Jia Tolentino writes about many different things but always through a lense of feminism and internet culture...
  • Kelly
    I really loved this. Ive been reading Jia Tolentinos stuff ever since she started at Jezebel- were roughly the same age and she got assigned stuff I was guaranteed to click on, so Ive read a fair amount. Some of her NYer pieces were even better, after she was freed from needing to write in Internet witty speak all the time and could show other tricks and styles she had up her sleeve. And Id say those two voices and experiences are about equally o...
  • Conor Ahern
    If the attendees of my gay book club and various members of grouptexts are any indication, the Jia hype is for real. She has become something of a tribune for the millennial generation: funny and razor sharp, introspective and curious, she writes in a way that very often feels inspired. I followed Jia as she developed through stints at the Awl, the Hairpin, Jezebel, and finally the New Yorker, where she seems to have finally encountered an audien...
  • Sarah
    It took me a while to get used to Jia Tolentino's style of writing (the essays jump around a bit at times and get a little stream of consciousness-y) but there are some real gems in this collection. For me she's at her best when talking about social media, gender, women and media, but I found something to admire or enjoy in almost all of the essays in this personal collection.Thank you Netgalley and 4th Estate for the advance copy, which was prov...
  • Katherine Elizabeth
    Some essays were monumentally better than others but, overall, I still wasn't too big of a fan. I guess I didn't agree with too much Jia wrote about, and there was nothing that "wowed" me.
  • Vanessa
    Wowee this girl knows how to write! Articulate, insightful, intelligent and informative. A true voice of her generation.
  • Claire Reads Books
    Fantastic ✨ The nine essays in this razor-sharp collection circle around the notions of identity and the self that have become all-important and inescapable in the Internet era. With remarkable clarity and her formidable intellect, Tolentino highlights the distortions and self-delusions that have festered on digital platforms and begun to spread into our analog livesand she considers the intellectual rewiring that might be necessary to free us ...
  • Perry
    RTC. An essay collection that's Fresh, Brilliant, Cerebrally Stimulating and Boundary-Expanding (for this Gen-X male, to be sure). The New Yorker has to be proud to have Jia Tolento as its millennial cultural critic. For the first time since I do not recall when, I am fired up about spending a few hours of my weekend revisiting several favorite parts of a book and writing a 5-star review.I am grateful to Random House and NetGalley for an ARC.
  • Jaime
    Im not sure I get the hype about Tolentino. Many times, I wanted to scream GET TO THE POINT with these essays. She goes off on tangents and reading this became more of an exercise in perseverance than anything else. Id give it 2.5 stars but rounded up. I’m not sure I get the hype about Tolentino. Many times, I wanted to scream GET TO THE POINT with these essays. She goes off on tangents and reading this became more of an exercise in persevera...
  • Lindsey
    I dont know if I can top the review that calls this a collection of high-functioning book reports but Ill try to elaborate. Tolentinos whole schtick is to take things that are underarticulated and explain them more thoroughly. Shes that person in the meeting who hears the hint of an idea and then takes it and runs with it without ever having an original thought or contribution of her own. Whats even more frustrating it that the ideas are trite, a...
  • Dan
    Jia Tolentinos Trick Mirror: Reflections on Self Delusion includes nine essays focusing on American identity, culture, technology, politics, and discourse. Tolentino wrote the essays in 2017 and 2018. Reflecting on this period, Tolentino writes that throughout this period, I found that I could hardly trust anything that I was thinking. A doubt that always hovers in the back of my mind intensified: that whatever conclusions I might reach about mys...
  • David Yoon
    It's a confidently smart collection of essays informed by a lifetime on writing on the internet. Which is to say a traditional collection of literary essays feels a bit one directional, the author invoking their well-researched thesis and disseminating it outward. Mic drop and move on. But on the internet, especially I imagine for a woman of colour with an opinion, there's an almost immediate response. Mansplaining in the comments, hot takes, int...
  • Alice
    I had to take breaks between these essays. They are so sharp and juicy and confronting, and needed time to absorb. This is the kind of book that makes you want to avoid reading anything else for a while, so that its ideas can keep ping-ponging around your brain undiluted. Between the waves of dread and horror at what the world (and more specifically, my own generation) has become, this book has also given me a thread of hope and clarity as to how...
  • Derek Ouyang
    This was a frustrating read. I can understand the hype because of Tolentino's overall on-point-ness and refreshing honesty on thorny cultural topics, but diving into the actual writing, I couldn't help but shake the feeling that these were like outstanding AP English essays whipped out by a student who had been partying all night with basic friends but could effortlessly crank out the winning formula of criticism topped with literary reference an...
  • Laurie Naranjo
    It pains me to give this a low rating, because the potential (and hype) is there. I wanted her point of view and inference and instead it was mishmash of citations and facts organized as prose. It felt like she was showing she did all of the research to prove a point but never actually got around to making the point. It felt timid in that way and wholly overworked.