Age of Betrayal by Jack Beatty

Age of Betrayal

Age of Betrayal is a brilliant reconsideration of America's first Gilded Age, when war-born dreams of freedom and democracy died of their impossibility. Focusing on the alliance between government and railroads forged by bribes and campaign contributions, Jack Beatty details the corruption of American political culture that, in the words of Rutherford B. Hayes, transformed “a government of the people, by the people, and for the people” into ...


Details Age of Betrayal

TitleAge of Betrayal
ISBN9781400040285
Author
Release DateApr 10th, 2007
PublisherKnopf
LanguageEnglish
GenreHistory, Nonfiction, Economics, North American Hi..., American History, Politics, Literature, American, Labor
Rating

Reviews Age of Betrayal

  • David Buckley
    1970-01-01
    Beatty's book is certainly combative enough and "passionate" enough to warrant some of the praise showered on it by media reviewers. But "passion" is too often a codeword for "bias," and congenial though Beattty's view of the Gilded Age may be, there is no denying its lopsidedness.In his opening sentence Beatty throws down the gauntlet: "This book tells the saddest story,"he writes. "How, having redeemed democracy in the Civil War, America betray...
  • Joe Hack
    1970-01-01
    History repeats itself, and the history the United States is repeating here in the early 21st Century is the period from 1865 to 1900 that historians often refer to as the Gilded Age. All the rights and freedoms promised by Abraham Lincoln were thrown into the dustbin of history by the alleged losers of the Civil War. Corporations became the beneficiaries of the war's only victories (the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments) and the reaper of America's...
  • Lauren Albert
    1970-01-01
    If you feel like getting really angry, read this book. It's not just about the way money bought politics--much more and much more openly then than now--but also about racism and the failure of reconstruction. I constantly felt like steam was going to come out of my ears. The book seemed weaker at the end but still well worth reading. If you want to get angry, anyway....
  • Erwin
    1970-01-01
    Jack Beatty's Age of Betrayal I have to say, was a thoroughly enjoyable and engrossing read. Mr. Beatty, who demonstrates his probity, erudition and understanding time and again on NPR's On Point, easily imports these virtues into writing. His is politically inflected historiography in the best sense, comparing favorably to Marxian British historians of previous generations like E. P. Thompson and Gareth Stedman Jones. For the author, what is pas...
  • Walt
    1970-01-01
    This book is not for the casual reader or the faint of heart. At close to 400 pages, Age of Betrayal is an undertaking. Beatty has demonstrated a thorough knowledge of the subject matter and supported his work with copious amounts of citations and references. His work falls short in the complexity of his subject and his writing style.Overall, this is an impressive book. I learned a lot by reading it. The Guilded Age was one of robber barons and c...
  • David Monroe
    1970-01-01
    Beatty's focus is on tracking the transformation of the late 19th Century through an in-depth examination of key events and representative biographies that highlight the alliance between government and business, including the Supreme Court's infamous Santa Clara decision (effectively extending equal protection rights to corporations), the bloody suppression of the Homestead strike, and the rise (and fall) of the Populist movement. This is the sto...
  • Michael
    1970-01-01
    Conservative historians like to complain that histories written with the present in mind results in bad history. This book proves that old saw to be, well, old. This book is a well written, carefully detailed (sometimes too detailed) and powerfully relevant history of the Gilded Age - the period of American history from the end of the Civil War to the Assassination of William McKinley. This was an era of unrestrained capitalist growth, the creati...
  • Jerry Landry
    1970-01-01
    While I think this book had some really fascinating facts and analysis in it and helped to improve my knowledge of the time between 1865 and 1900 in the US, I almost feel that it would have been better served to have had its subject matter divided up into a few books. As a reader, I felt disoriented jumping from two chapters about the Supreme Court to two chapters about Tom Scott and the Pennsylvania Railroad to a chapter about Populism and so on...
  • Brandon
    1970-01-01
    This is a first-rate history of the Gilded Age that shows very clearly the betrayal Beatty's title refers to -- how special interests managed to corrupt the government and one of its noblest achievements (the 14th Amendment) to empower corporations. It's a searing book about how the system once worked against the very people government is supposed to protect -- we the people -- and instead became an instrument for the wealthy and powerful to prot...
  • Zack Anchors
    1970-01-01
    All those people chattering so much about "populist rage" these days need to read this book, a history of late 19th century populist uprising and related events. Then, as now, vigorous debate over substantive economic issues became watered down by the infusion into the political discourse of completely phony issues -- most notably the "currency question". Ultimately, whether the US used silver or gold as the standard for its currency didn't matte...
  • Bill
    1970-01-01
    I think the late 19th century is very interesting... especially compared to the current politics. This is a very liberal biased look at that time but, being very liberal, I found little that was amiss!It was the gilded age - the time of the Robber Barons - the civil war was over and the United States were becoming the dominant power in the world....if not in military strength at least in economic reach.Slavery had all but returned in the South wi...
  • Sabrine Faragallah
    1970-01-01
    Fantastic read, especially for anyone interested in a true, un-filtered understanding of the Reconstruction Era of US history and what the start of industrialization really looked like in the US.Another great takeaway was insight to the modern day foundation of the Democratic and Republican parties, and the Populist and Progressive undercurrents that were disruptive forces and shaped our history and the ideals of each of the parties.A great find ...
  • Robert Garcia
    1970-01-01
    A rambling, analogy-ridden book that skips it's way through the details of the titular era. While the subject matter is, by itself, too broad of a subject to accomplish with any single volume in the style of the author's verbose, quote-driven writing; the text somehow still manages to disconnect the natural narrative turns of the period and ham-hands several poor segues onto us (the most notable occuring between Chs. 6-7)
  • B
    1970-01-01
    This seems to be a common theme among books arguing that there was a particular time when business became more powerful in American society: They always seem to hint at an alternative but don't really seem to have it. At any rate, this book is full of interesting statistics and stories. They may not all add up to anything in particular but they certainly add color
  • Toothy_grin
    1970-01-01
    A most impressive piece of Gilded Age scholarship (The end notes are amazing.) conveyed in a dismal style of writing. Gratuitous over-usage of obscure words sent me to the dictionary too often, and numerous sentences took multiple readings to parse their meanings. That said, it's an important book on one of the crucial eras of American history: read it, but keep your dictionary at hand.
  • david
    1970-01-01
    Beatty tells engaging stories about politics, law, industry, labor and reform in post civil war america showing how the rich got richer and the poor got poorer. Perhaps most disturbing is the way in which an industry friendly and racist supreme court interpreted the 14th amendment as protecting the "privileges and immunities" of corporations but not freed slaves as was intended.
  • Jack
    1970-01-01
    I generally agree with Jack Beatty's interpretations and judgments on the topic. However, this book suffers from poor organization, lack of focus, and truly opaque writing. Regrettably it's one of the very few nonfiction books that I consider "unreadable".
  • Paula
    1970-01-01
    Not an easy read (too many quotes, too much material to synthesize) but a most interesting look at the economic and political history of the "Gilded Age". It doesn't sound much different from the way things are today, unfortunately--entirely too much corporate influence.
  • Victor
    1970-01-01
    Very interesting book if someone wants to better understand the background for today's corporate - legal - political landscape and how it came into being. The book can be a bit slow in places but overall still very interesting and informative.
  • Sean Chick
    1970-01-01
    Disorganized, ham-fisted, and supported by a poor use of source. Oh, and he gets lots of basic facts wrong. But hey, when you are part of the intellectual elite, you get a free pass to fail. What is true has become true on Wall Street is true in scholarship.
  • Rebecca
    1970-01-01
    Such an interesting topic....presented in the most boring possible way.
  • Susan
    1970-01-01
    Very uneven - the first five chapters were truly fascinating, but nothing following matched that level. Perhaps the author was less interested in the later material?
  • Christopher
    1970-01-01
    Great economic and political history of the Gilded Age. Highly relevant the present era.
  • Sicarii
    1970-01-01
    Too much about modern issues, rather than the period covered.